Jails: America's Mental HospitalsPhoto essayIn Jail or in TreatmentPollStatisticsResources
Getting 62 Years | A Good Boy Turned Sick? | The Hinckley Factor | Not Crazy Enough
"A very serious mistake" | Conclusion

Psychiatrist Richard Barrett was hired by Zwack's lawyers to examine Kyle. After several hours of interviews and a survey of the young man's psychiatric history, Barrett concluded that, yes, Kyle Zwack was insane even by the strict M'Naghten standard used in Texas.

"It wasn't close," Barrett says today. "He didn't know what he was doing."

Barrett interviewed Zwack for several hours. Yes, he acknowledges, even without medication Kyle spoke with "lucidity." "But you know a lot of people who are schizophrenic do. It's not like they just talk gibberish to you. But he had a very fixed delusional system. If he wanted to let you know what it was, it was there and it was very powerful."

By "fixed delusional system," Barrett means a tightly-held set of beliefs that bear no relation to reality—a classic symptom of paranoid schizophrenia. Zwack believed he was on a righteous mission to battle police and other shadowy forces who were conspiring against him, Barrett found.

Excerpts of the transcript from Kyle Zwack's federal trial in 1988. Allowed by the court to represent himself, Kyle claimed he was on a mission for the CIA. He asked to call then-President Bush as a witness to vouch for his status as a secret agent.

You'll need the free Adobe Acrobat reader to read these files.

For further evidence of Zwack's insanity, defense attorney John Ackerman pointed to the Omega Project. That's the name Kyle had given to an elaborate plan he'd drawn up on his computer—a plan to build a machine-gun turret on the back of his pickup truck, load the vehicle full of explosives and drive it under the Hennepin County Government Center, blowing up the 25-story building.

Nonetheless, at his trial, mental health experts for the prosecution testified Zwack was sane. At the time, psychologist Jerome Brown did routine mental examinations for the Harris County courts. He says he remembers the Zwack case only faintly. "But apparently I did not find any evidence of the delusions and the altered perception of reality that perhaps the defense attorneys were claiming."

Brown's testimony was based on a one-hour interview with Zwack. And unlike mental experts for the defense, Brown was not told about Zwack's psychiatric history or his plan for mass-destruction, the Omega Project. Told about those things twelve years later, Brown says Zwack must have decided to hide his delusions during their interview.

"Strangely enough," he says, "many of these people would rather be found guilty of a crime than to be called crazy and so they will actually withhold the very symptoms and evidence that might exonerate them. It may be that we missed all of this and that he may have been genuinely much sicker than we were able to determine at the time."

Following testimony from Brown and another expert that Zwack was sane, the Houston jury returned its verdict: guilty. One juror who asked that his name not be used told us he didn't think Zwack had a mental problem; Kyle was just "a violent person"...a "troublemaker," the juror said.

Another juror, Roy Sandoval, was willing to speak about the case in more detail. He said most on the jury thought Zwack was mentally ill, but not that ill. "He was a bright kid, apparently, and there just wasn't enough evidence to show that he was completely out of his mind."

Still, Sandoval says, several jurors were sympathetic to the notion that Zwack might be legally insane. Discussion in the jury room turned to the question of what would happen if Kyle were acquitted and set free.

"The concern was that he would be let out in the general population. I think a lot of people understood that he had problems that had to be dealt with, and he was old enough to make up his own mind, and if his parents would want him to be committed or have some sort of therapy, that he was old enough to say, 'No, I don't want it,' and go out and commit the same crime again, or another crime."

Next: "A Very Serious Mistake"



©2018 American Public Media